Which brand wins over the craft cutting world between Brother Scan and Cut vs Cricut?

While each has its unique value proposition, there are large overlaps between them as well.

To help you understand what is necessary for you, we’ll break down and examine in detail the most advanced model from both Brother and Cricut. 

Brother Scan and Cut vs Cricut Maker

It might not be the most popular electric die cutter in the crafting world, but we cannot overlook Brother Scan and Cut’s quality and brand ability.

On the flip side, Cricut is a giant in the industry. It is well known for the delivery of excellent cuts.

We’re going to test the most advanced model of each brand—Brother Scan and Cut 2 and Cricut Maker and three features that matter most during craft cutting.

We’re going to check:

1. The cutting power
2. Versatility
3. Value for Money

Brother Scan and Cut

Brother Scan and Cut is an electronic machine that targets hobbyist crafters. It first entered the market in 2015.

Its unique feature is the in-built scanner that presents a new set of possibilities when crafting.

Versatility

Brother Scan and Cut comes with tons of new unique features.

For instance, it has a unique built-in scanner that scans virtually everything, without the use of a computer to automatically generate customized cut designs. What’s more, it has enhanced scanning that enables even color recognition during scans.

Overall, Brother Scan and Cut 2 wins the versatility features because of the additional scan utility.

Value for Money

If you’re a hobbyist or a home crafter, the versatility of Brother Scan and Cut gives you value for your money. The scan feature is overly powerful and readily generates a design out of anything it scans. Besides that, it has more accessory tools to draw, write, score, and even import designs from your PC or mobile device.

However, Brother Scan and Cut isn’t suitable for heavy-duty. It only handles lightweight projects correctly. But it is the cheapest versatile electronic machine. If you’re crafting just as a hobby, the tool gives you the highest value for money.

When it comes to value on money, Brother Scan and Cut and Cricut Maker are tied.

Power

When it comes to performance, Brother Scan and Cut is not an underdog. It comes with German Carbide Blade with design Japan Design quality to offer precision and best quality cut.

What’s more, it works with two mat sizes—the 12” x 12” and the 12” x 14” mats.

However, the power of this machine is only a fraction of the Cricut Maker. When it comes to power, Cricut Maker comes out on top.

Pros

• Extraordinarily versatile and presents nearly all creative options of the designing world
• Relatively cheap to suit your hobby needs
• Has a powerful scanning ability that can generate designs out of everything
• Supports wireless design transfer

Cons

• Will not handle heavy-duty correctly
• The machine is limited to material up to 2 millimeters

Cricut Maker

Cricut Maker is the world’s most powerful cutting machine with a cutting force of 4kg.

It comes with more tools, more possibilities, and the ability to handle different materials. In fact, it deals with nearly every crafting material you can use in designing.

Versatility

Cricut Maker combines an expandable suite of tools for writing, scoring, cutting, and adding decorative effects. These cater for all your creative needs as you master each new craft.

However, Brother Scan and Cut has all these features plus a scan feature that generates designs from scanning any image. This feature gives Brother Scan and Cut a marginal lead over Cricut Maker on versatility.

Value for Your Money

Cricut Maker handles nearly every material you’d want to craft with.

Besides that, it presents a wide range of tools to execute virtually every project you can imagine. It comes with pens and markers that allow you to draw attention to detail.

Cricut Maker allows you to choose from 500+ digital sewing patterns in just a few clicks. All these features offer value for money.

However, Cricut Maker lacks the scanning feature, which might limit your creativity.

What’s more, it is $100 more expensive than the Brother Scan and Cut. If you’re only designing as a hobby, it might be slightly expensive to spend on it.

All in all, it is a tie when it comes to value for money.

Power

If you ask any crafter, you’ll hear, Cricut Maker is the most powerful machine you can find on the market today. To begin with, it has the highest cutting force in the industry.

Secondly, it is non-oppressive when it comes to the material it can handle. It can handle nearly all types of materials like paper, leather, iron-ons, balsa, vinyl, fabric, etc.

Thirdly, it employs a suite of tools. With its powerful blades, pens, and scoring tools, Cricut Maker presents a brand new world of possibilities.

Cricut Maker takes a big lead when it comes to power.

Pros

• Accurately handles heavy-duty because it can handle nearly all material you can use to design
• Offers real value for your money as it is non-oppressive when it comes to the weight of the project
• It is the best craft cutting machine on the market
• Easy to use

Cons

• Lacks scanning utility—it cannot extract designs from scanning materials
• It is pricey if you’re only acquiring it to craft for hobby
• A bit complicated when handling projects more than 12” wide

Conclusion 

Looking at both of these two machines, they both have their pros and cons.

But it hugely depends on the intended project types you want to execute. If you’re going to craft just for hobby, Brother Scan and Cut will serve you well.

And if you intend to execute some serious and heavy-duty designing, Cricut maker won’t disappoint.

Even though versatile, Brother Scan and Cut 2 is only appropriate for lightweight tasks. But Cricut Maker is non-oppressive on the weight of the project ahead.

Overall, you can’t go wrong with either of them. They all have their nuances.

It is all about finding the one that suits your type of project.